| Sam Nwadike | 2013-14 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Frantz Pinard | 2013-14 | GNAC Rookie of the Year |
| Curtis Cassella | 2013-14 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Matt Pepdjonovic | 2012-13 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Colin Halpin | 2012-13 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Courtyard by Marriot Tip-Off All-Tournament Team | ||
| Caleb Unni | 2012-13 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Matt Pepdjonovic | 2011-12 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Carlos De La Cruz | 2011-12 | GNAC All-Sportsmanship Team |
| Matt Pepdjonovic | 2010-11 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Matt Pepdjonovic | 2009-10 | GNAC Rookie of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference Third Team | ||
| Brian Small | 2008-09 | ESPN the Magazine Academic All-America |
| Espn the Magazine Academic All-District | ||
| GNAC Team All-Conference Third Team | ||
| Brian Small | 2006-07 | CoSIDA Academic All-American |
| CoSIDA Academic All-District | ||
| John Murphy | 2006-07 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| John Murphy | 2005-06 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Eric Jenkins | 2003-04 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Tom Carey | 2002-03 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jason Luisi | 2001-02 | GNAC Tournament MVP |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Winston Daley | 2001-02 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Jason Luisi | 2000-01 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Dan Florian | 2000-01 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Dan Florian | 1999-00 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |