| Tyler Parmelee | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Ben Daniels | 2013 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Ben Rollins | 2012 | CoSIDA Capital One Academic All-District |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| Nick DiCicco | 2012 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Noah Leone | 2012 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Danny Lloyd | 2011 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| James Harvey | 2011 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Ben Rollins | 2010 | GNAC Tournament MVP |
| Danny Lloyd | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| David Best | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Nicholas DiCicco | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Luis Flores | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Nick Cugine | 2010 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Jeff Williams | 2010 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Danny Lloyd | 2009 | GNAC Player of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Nick Celia | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Bernhard Lotterer | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jack DeJesus | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Nick Celia | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Danny Lloyd | 2008 | GNAC Rookie of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| Clayton Plumer | 2008 | GNAC All-Sportsmanship Team |
| GNAC All-Conference Third Team | ||
| Cristian Palcios | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Nick Celia | 2006 | GNAC Rookie of the Year |
| Babacar Ndour | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Kevin Rogers | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Emilio Casano | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Babacar Ndour | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Marco D'Andrea | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Babacar Ndour | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Justin Bevis | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Bryan Courtney | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Zach Courts | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Justin Bevis | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Kevin Rogers | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Oscar DelPonto Canas | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Kerim Debabi | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |