| Erin McAndrews | 2014 | NFCA All-Northeast Region First Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Sarah Chasse | 2014 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Liz Martel | 2014 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Lindsay Pagano | 2014 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Erin McAndrews | 2013 | NFCA All-Northeast Region First Team |
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Sarah Chasse | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Alicia Gonnella | 2013 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Erin McAndrews | 2012 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Samantha McGilvray | 2012 | GNAC All-Sportsmanship Team |
| Lauren Barrett | 2011 | GNAC All-Sportsmanship Team |
| Clara Conklin | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Valerie Liberatore | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Cali Loura | 2010 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Jess Ferriera | 2009 | NFCA 3rd Team All-America |
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Marie Trainor | 2009 | NFCA 3rd Team All-Region |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Monica Cioffi | 2009 | ESPN the Magazine Academic All-District |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| Rebecca Barnett | 2009 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Jess Ferreira | 2008 | GNAC Player of the Year |
| GNAC First Team All-Conference | ||
| Ashley Gaboriault | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Monica Cioffi | 2008 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Jess Ferreira | 2007 | GNAC Player of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| NEISCA All-New England (Honorable Mention) | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Ashley Gaboriault | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Valerie Liberatore | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Natalie West | 2007 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Jenn Elwell | 2007 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Jess Ferreira | 2006 | NFCA Second Team All-American |
| GNAC Rookie of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| NFCA All-Region (2nd Team) | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Jen Elwell | 2006 | GNAC Pitcher of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Angela Belanger | 2006 | CoSIDA Academic All-District |
| NEISCA All-New England (1st Team) | ||
| Brenna Burr | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Natalie West | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Erin Pagel | 2005 | NEISCA All-New England (1st Team) |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Katie Crowley | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Christina Nay | 2005 | NEISCA All-New England (2nd Team) |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Brenna Burr | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Jill Grant | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Natalie West | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Erin Pagel | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Lynn Bennett | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Angela Belanger | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Erin Pagel | 2003 | ECAC All-Star |
| NEISCA All-New England | ||
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Lauren Uttaro | 2003 | NFCA All-Region (2nd Team) |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Emily Cullen | 2003 | NFCA All-Region (3rd Team) |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Christina Nay | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Erin Pagel | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Kathleen Tolson | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Amber Conte | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Katie Norton | 2000 | GNAC Player of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Kathleen Tolson | 2000 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Katie Norton | 1999 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Amber Conte | 1999 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Katie Norton | 1998 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Holly Strasiowski | 1998 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Katie Norton | 1997 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Michelle Mayo | 1997 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jen Connelly | 1996 | NEISCA All-New England (2nd Team) |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Erica Peterson | 1996 | 2nd Team All-Northeast |