| Jake Cintolo | 2014 | D3Baseball.com Preseason All-American |
| Capital One Academic All-District | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Devan Jones | 2014 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| JC Collette | 2014 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Matt Brenner | 2014 | ECAC Tournament MVP |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Rob Marks | 2014 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Mac Jacobson | 2014 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Jhonneris Mendez | 2014 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Tim Conroy | 2014 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| James McConville | 2014 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Mike Cunningham | 2013 | ABCA/Rawlings Second Team All-American |
| NEIBA First Team All-New England | ||
| ECAC Second Team All-Star | ||
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Jake Cintolo | 2013 | Capital One Academic All-District |
| NEIBA All-New England First Team | ||
| ECAC First Team All-Star | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Chris Stanley | 2013 | NEIBA Third Team All-Region |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| GNAC Sportsmanship Team | ||
| Mike Muse | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Devan Jones | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| JC Collette | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Josh Desai | 2013 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Jonathan Richard | 2013 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Jhonneris Mendez | 2012 | NEIBA All-New England Second Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Jake Cintolo | 2012 | GNAC All-New England Third Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Devan Jones | 2012 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Chris Stanley | 2012 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Mac Jacobson | 2012 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Tim Belanger | 2012 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Jake Cintolo | 2011 | NEIBA All-New England Second Team |
| GNAC Rookie of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Devan Jones | 2011 | NEIBA All-New England Second Team |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| Alex Torres | 2011 | GNAC Pitcher of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Mark Annese | 2011 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| GNAC Sportsmanship Team | ||
| Mark Addesa | 2011 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Andrew Babb | 2011 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Charles Kilgore | 2011 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Nick Travelyn | 2011 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Matt Sliney | 2011 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Bobby Barrett | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Rory Gentile | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jhonneris Mendez | 2010 | GNAC Rookie of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| Andrew Babb | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Alex Torres | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Chris Stanley | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Nick Travelyn | 2010 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Matt Sliney | 2010 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Eric Del Buono | 2010 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Bobby Barrett | 2009 | D3Baseball.com All-American Honorable Mention |
| NEIBA All-New England First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Tim Doyle | 2009 | NEIBA All-New England Third Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Rory Gentile | 2009 | ESPN the Magazine Academic All-District |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Mark Addesa | 2009 | GNAC Tournament MVP |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Paul Vittozzi | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Dan Delia | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Reid Jackson | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Keith Carter | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Jon Handy | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Mike Kenneally | 2009 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Alex Torres | 2009 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Anthony Iacopucci | 2009 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Nick Martinho | 2008 | NEIBA All-New England First Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Dan Delia | 2008 | NEIBA All-New England Second Team |
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Steve Durant | 2008 | GNAC Pitcher of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Keith Carter | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Bobby Barrett | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jose Alejandro | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Tim Corcoran | 2008 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Greg Dimarco | 2008 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Matt Shanahan | 2008 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Nick Martinho | 2007 | NEIBA All-New England Second Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Greg DiMarco | 2007 | NEIBA All-New England Third Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Marc Exarhopoulos | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jeison King | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Kevin Silva | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Steve Durant | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Reid Jackson | 2007 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Dan Delia | 2007 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Tom Kelley | 2007 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Mark Pinnetti | 2006 | GNAC Rookie of the Year |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Rony Mercado | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Trevor Grimshaw | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jared Blandino | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Marc Exarhopoulos | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Nick Martinho | 2006 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Tamayo Manzanillo | 2005 | NEIBA All-New England First Team |
| ECAC All-Star First Team | ||
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC Tournament MVP | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| CBUAO Sportsmanship Award | ||
| Mike Maguire | 2005 | NEIBA All-New England First Team |
| ECAC All-Star First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Matt Batchelder | 2005 | NEIBA All-New England Third Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| CoSIDA Academic All-District | ||
| Nick Martinho | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Steve Durant | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Marc Exarhopoulos | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Rony Mercado | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Kevin Reedy | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Justin Waskiewicz | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Tamayo Manzanillo | 2004 | NEIBA All-New England First Team |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Mike Maguire | 2004 | NEIBA All-New England First Team |
| ECAC All-Star First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Matt Batchelder | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| CoSIDA Academic All-District | ||
| Rony Mercado | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Trevor Grimshaw | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Mike Maguire | 2003 | ABCA All-American Second Team |
| NEIBA All-New England First Team | ||
| ECAC All-Star First Team | ||
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Anthony Del Prete | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Pat Murphy | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Trevor Grimshaw | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Billy Waters | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Matt Batchelder | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Bryan McManaway | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Mike Rigazio | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Anthony Del Prete | 2002 | NEIBA All-New England Third Team |
| GNAC Pitcher of the Year | ||
| GNAC Tournament MVP | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Mike Maguire | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Adam Pellerin | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Tim Fraser | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Pat Young | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Kris Stokes | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Joe Duca | 2001 | NEIBA All-New England |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Eric Correira | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Jared Leach | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Billy Waters | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Kris Stokes | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Max Nunez | 2000 | ABCA All-American Second Team |
| NEIBA All-New England First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Conference Second Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Joe Duca | 2000 | NEIBA All-New England First Team |
| GNAC Player of the Year | ||
| GNAC Tournament MVP | ||
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Mike Anastasia | 2000 | NEIBA All-New England |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Peter Quinn | 2000 | NEIBA All-New England |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| Gabe Soto | 2000 | NEIBA All-New England |
| GNAC All-Conference First Team | ||
| GNAC All-Tournament Team | ||
| Nick Melchionna | 2000 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Jared Leach | 2000 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |