| Savannah Carpenter | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Tori Brillaud | 2013 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Katie Babb | 2013 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Hannah Davis | 2012 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Tanya Fortes | 2011 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Maggie Hillman | 2010 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Julie Sullivan | 2009 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Melissa Griffin | 2008 | GNAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Heather Cox | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Kristen Conrad | 2006 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Katie Hemlin | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Kristen Conrad | 2005 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Katie Hemlin | 2004 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Jennifer Harrington | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Erin McMenimen | 2003 | GNAC All-Conference Third Team |
| Erin McMenimen | 2002 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Erin McMenimen | 2001 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Ashley Begin | 1999 | GNAC All-Conference First Team |
| Ashley Begin | 1998 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Tif Norstedt | 1997 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |
| Jen Covino | 1997 | GNAC All-Tournament Team |
| Tugba Viral | 1996 | GNAC All-Conference Second Team |